The UK Commonhold System: A Paradigm Shift in Property Ownership

Introduction

The traditional property ownership model for flats in the UK has predominantly been defined by the leasehold system, where ownership is time-bound and subject to the dynamics of a landlord-leaseholder relationship. The introduction of the commonhold system through the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002 marked a significant departure, offering an alternative that promised greater autonomy and permanence for property owners. This article explores the nuances of the commonhold system, its operational mechanics, and the ways it differs from the traditional leasehold system, particularly in terms of service charges, reserve funds, interim payments, and future reforms.

The Commonhold System: An Overview

Commonhold, a concept introduced in the UK in 2002, represents a form of freehold property ownership, particularly suitable for flats and other interdependent buildings. Distinct from leasehold, commonhold tenure is indefinite, eliminating the depreciating asset concern inherent in leasehold, where property values diminish as the lease term nears expiration.It aligns more closely with international systems like Australia's Strata Title and North America's condominium system. Despite its potential, commonhold uptake has been low, primarily due to its competition with the more established leasehold model.

Contrasting Commonhold and Leasehold Relationships

In leasehold, the relationship between landlord and leaseholder often involves complex dynamics, with the landlord retaining significant control over the property. Commonhold, conversely, entails a more democratic structure. Property owners are not only freehold proprietors of their units but also members of the commonhold association, a collective body that manages the property. This structure fosters a community-driven approach, with decisions made collectively by unit owners.

Maintenance Charges: A New Approach

One of the critical differences between commonhold and leasehold is the approach to service charges. In a leasehold, service charges are often a point of contention, lacking transparency and predictability. Commonhold addresses this through the Commonhold Community Statement (CCS), which clearly delineates the rights and duties regarding maintenance charges, offering a more transparent and equitable framework.

Reserve Funds and Financial Management

In terms of reserve funds, the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002 provides for the establishment of reserve funds in commonhold, but unlike leasehold, it does not mandate their creation. The decision to establish a reserve fund is at the discretion of the directors of the commonhold association, who must consider a reserve study at least once every ten years. This approach grants more flexibility compared to leasehold arrangements, where reserve funds are often legally required and rigidly structured.

Interim Payments and Making Payments

The commonhold system also introduces a structured approach to interim payments and financial contributions. Unit-holders are required to meet financial demands within specified timeframes, as outlined in various forms such as the commonhold assessment and emergency assessment. This clarity contrasts with the often unpredictable and opaque nature of service charges in leaseholds. Moreover, the commonhold model allows for the recovery of dues from rents paid by third parties to unit-holders, providing an additional layer of financial security for the commonhold association.

Future Reforms and the Path Forward

Despite its advantages, the adoption of commonhold has been slow, with its competition against the leasehold model being a significant factor. However, legislative changes such as the Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act aim to level the playing field for commonhold. The government has also established the Commonhold Council to prepare homeowners and the market for commonhold's widespread adoption. These efforts, coupled with the Law Commission's recommendations for reforms to the commonhold legislation, signal a potential reinvigoration of commonhold as a viable alternative to leasehold.

So what’s the catch?

Despite the wonder of the advantages referred to here, commonhold isn’t a utopia. Buildings still need to be managed, service charges collected, contracts signed. The landlord/leaseholder relationship sets a clear hierarchy for decision making, the commonhold system muddies the waters in the name of giving all residents a say. That’s great in principle, but many flat owners and landlords will be aware of the varying opinions among residents. Distant buy-to-let landlords may veto or delay an internal common parts refurbishment, while a resident owner is strongly in favour. The commonhold system complicates this decision-making process. This among other aspects of commonhold creates uncertainty.

Conclusion

The commonhold system presents a revolutionary approach to property ownership, offering indefinite tenure, a democratic management structure, and transparent financial mechanisms. It addresses several issues inherent in the leasehold system, such as depreciating lease terms and opaque service charges. While its adoption has been limited, ongoing legislative reforms and government support may pave the way for its broader acceptance. As property ownership evolves in the UK, commonhold stands as a promising alternative, fostering a more equitable and participatory model for managing shared property. But it may not be the golden panacea some would like it to be.

Are you impacted by the issues raised in this article?

Enjoyed this article?

Sign up for our newsletter where we share our thoughts on the latest industry updates, summarise articles behind paywalls, and provide value-added, in-depth analysis on all things residential block management.

Bovellan is a leading residential block property managing agent based in London. We specialise in providing comprehensive residential block property management services tailored to the unique needs of Victorian and period residential blocks.

Blog

The UK Commonhold System: A Paradigm Shift in Property Ownership